Determination of Apparent Viscosity of Engine Oils Using the Cold-Cranking Simulator (ASTM D5293 / ISO 2909)
🔹 Purpose of the Test
The Cold-Cranking Simulator (CCS) test evaluates the low-temperature viscosity of engine oils. This is essential because:
✅ Ensures proper engine startup in cold weather
✅ Determines oil flow characteristics at low temperatures
✅ Prevents excessive engine wear due to poor lubrication
📌 Oils that are too thick in cold conditions can cause hard starting or even engine failure.
🔹 Key Test Parameters
✔ Apparent Viscosity (cP) – Measured in centipoise (cP)
✔ Test Temperature (°C) – Typically ranges from -10°C to -35°C, depending on the oil grade
✔ Shear Rate – Simulates engine startup conditions
📌 Results determine compliance with SAE J300 viscosity classifications for engine oils.
🔹 Required Equipment & Materials
✔ Cold-Cranking Simulator (CCS) – Measures viscosity under high shear rates
✔ Cooling System – Maintains precise test temperature
✔ Viscometer Cells – Holds the oil sample during the test
✔ Certified Engine Oil Sample – Preconditioned before testing
✔ Thermometer & Timer – Ensures accurate temperature control
🔹 Step-by-Step Test Procedure
Step 1: Sample Preparation
1️⃣ Condition the Oil Sample – Pre-cool the oil to the target test temperature.
2️⃣ Fill the CCS Test Chamber – Ensure there are no air bubbles.
3️⃣ Insert into Cooling System – Maintain at the required test temperature.
📌 Why? Proper preconditioning ensures accurate and repeatable results.
Step 2: Cold-Cranking Simulation
4️⃣ Apply Shear Stress – The simulator spindle rotates at a controlled speed.
5️⃣ Measure Apparent Viscosity – The instrument records resistance to flow in cP.
6️⃣ Repeat for Multiple Temperatures – If required for broader analysis.
📌 Why? This mimics how an oil behaves when an engine tries to crank in freezing temperatures.
🔹 Interpretation of Results
| SAE Viscosity Grade | Maximum CCS Viscosity (cP) at Test Temperature (°C) |
|---|---|
| 0W-XX | 6200 cP at -35°C |
| 5W-XX | 6600 cP at -30°C |
| 10W-XX | 7000 cP at -25°C |
| 15W-XX | 7000 cP at -20°C |
| 20W-XX | 9500 cP at -15°C |
📌 Oils must meet these limits to be classified under SAE J300 winter grades.
🔹 Factors Affecting Viscosity Performance
✅ Base Oil Type – Synthetic oils typically perform better at low temperatures
✅ Viscosity Modifiers – Additives improve cold flow properties
✅ Shear Stability – Oils must maintain viscosity under stress
✅ Contaminants & Oxidation – Can thicken oil, affecting results
🔹 Common Issues & Troubleshooting
| Problem | Possible Cause | Solution |
|---|---|---|
| High viscosity (poor cold start) | Low-quality base oil or insufficient additives | Use high-VI synthetic oils |
| Inconsistent results | Poor temperature control | Ensure precise cooling system calibration |
| Air bubbles in sample | Improper sample handling | Degas oil before testing |
| Excessive variability | Contaminated oil | Use fresh, certified oil samples |
🔹 Applications in Industry
✔ Automotive Lubricants – Ensures winter performance of engine oils
✔ Heavy-Duty Vehicles – Prevents startup failures in extreme cold
✔ Oil Formulation & R&D – Helps develop low-temperature lubricants
✔ Quality Control Labs – Ensures oils meet SAE standards
Comparison of Viscosity Test Methods for Lubricating Oils
Different viscosity test methods measure various aspects of oil flow behavior under different conditions. Below is a comparison of major viscosity tests, including Cold-Cranking Simulator (CCS) – ASTM D5293, Kinematic Viscosity – ASTM D445, Brookfield Viscosity – ASTM D2983, and Gelation Index – ASTM D5133.
🔹 Comparison Table: Viscosity Test Methods
| Test Method | Measured Parameter | Conditions | Application | SAE J300 Relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ASTM D445 (Kinematic Viscosity) | Viscosity (cSt) | 40°C & 100°C | General viscosity measurement for engine & industrial oils | Defines SAE “XX” grade (e.g., 10W-30 → “30” refers to kinematic viscosity at 100°C) |
| ASTM D5293 (Cold-Cranking Simulator – CCS) | Apparent Viscosity (cP) | -10°C to -35°C (high shear) | Low-temperature startup performance | Defines SAE “W” grade (e.g., 10W-30 → “10W” refers to CCS viscosity at -25°C) |
| ASTM D4684 (Mini-Rotary Viscometer – MRV) | Yield stress & low-temp viscosity (cP) | -10°C to -40°C (static) | Measures pumpability at cold temperatures | Used to determine oil pumpability limits in extreme cold |
| ASTM D2983 (Brookfield Viscosity) | Low-shear viscosity (cP) | -10°C to -40°C | Gear oils, ATF, hydraulic fluids | Not used for SAE J300, but relevant for transmission & hydraulic fluids |
| ASTM D5133 (Gelation Index) | Gelation tendency | -10°C to -40°C | Determines risk of oil gelation at low temperatures | Complementary to MRV for winter performance |
🔹 Key Differences in Viscosity Tests
1️⃣ CCS (ASTM D5293) vs. MRV (ASTM D4684)
📌 CCS (Cold-Cranking Simulator) measures cranking resistance, while MRV (Mini-Rotary Viscometer) measures pumpability resistance.
✅ CCS simulates the starter motor cranking load during cold starts (dynamic test).
✅ MRV simulates how oil flows through an engine’s oil pump (static test).
✅ CCS is used to define SAE “W” grades, while MRV determines if an oil has pumpability issues (yield stress limits).
🔍 Example: A 5W-30 oil should have:
- CCS viscosity ≤ 6600 cP at -30°C (ASTM D5293)
- MRV viscosity ≤ 60,000 cP at -35°C with no yield stress (ASTM D4684)
2️⃣ CCS (ASTM D5293) vs. Kinematic Viscosity (ASTM D445)
📌 ASTM D5293 measures dynamic viscosity at low temperatures, while ASTM D445 measures kinematic viscosity at 40°C & 100°C.
✅ Kinematic Viscosity (ASTM D445) is used to classify oils at operating temperatures, defining the second part of the SAE grade (e.g., 5W-30 → “30” refers to kinematic viscosity at 100°C).
✅ CCS (ASTM D5293) is for cold-cranking performance, while D445 is for normal engine operating conditions.
🔍 Example:
- A 10W-40 oil should have:
- CCS viscosity ≤ 7000 cP at -25°C (ASTM D5293)
- Kinematic viscosity between 12.5 – 16.3 cSt at 100°C (ASTM D445)
3️⃣ CCS (ASTM D5293) vs. Brookfield (ASTM D2983)
📌 CCS measures dynamic viscosity at high shear rates, while Brookfield measures low-shear viscosity for gear and transmission fluids.
✅ Brookfield Viscosity (ASTM D2983) is mainly used for gear oils, automatic transmission fluids (ATF), and hydraulic fluids, not for engine oils.
✅ CCS (ASTM D5293) applies to engine oils and is part of the SAE J300 viscosity classification.
🔍 Example:
- A 75W-90 gear oil is tested using Brookfield viscosity at -40°C (ASTM D2983)
- A 5W-30 engine oil is tested using CCS at -30°C (ASTM D5293)
🔹 Summary: Which Test Should You Use?
| If You Want to Measure… | Use This Test | SAE J300? |
|---|---|---|
| Viscosity at normal operating temperatures | ASTM D445 (Kinematic) | ✅ Yes |
| Cold-cranking performance (engine start in cold weather) | ASTM D5293 (CCS) | ✅ Yes |
| Cold pumpability (oil circulation in extreme cold) | ASTM D4684 (MRV) | ✅ Yes |
| Transmission, gear, and hydraulic fluid viscosity at low temperatures | ASTM D2983 (Brookfield) | ❌ No |
| Oil gelation risk at low temperatures | ASTM D5133 (Gelation Index) | ❌ No |
🔹 Conclusion
- ASTM D5293 (CCS) is critical for defining an oil’s winter grade (e.g., 0W, 5W, 10W).
- ASTM D4684 (MRV) complements CCS by ensuring cold-weather pumpability.
- ASTM D445 (Kinematic Viscosity) is used for SAE “XX” grades (e.g., 30, 40, 50).
- ASTM D2983 (Brookfield) is used for non-engine oils like gear oils and ATFs.
- ASTM D5133 (Gelation Index) helps assess cold-weather oil flow risks.
📌 For complete viscosity profiling, use CCS (D5293), MRV (D4684), and Kinematic Viscosity (D445) together!